Joe Burrow Trade Theories Are Taking Over the Vikings' Offseason

This post was originally published on this site.

Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow (9) walks for the locker room after the fourth quarter of the NFL Week 6 game between the Cincinnati Bengals and the Seattle Seahawks at Paycor Stadium in downtown Cincinnati on Sunday, Oct. 15, 2023. The Bengals improved to 3-3 on the season with a 17-13 at home. © Sam Greene/The Enquirer / USA TODAY NETWORK.

Until there’s reason for the rumor to die, Minnesota Vikings fans will believe that Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow is in play via trade. Burrow expressed frustration down the stretch of the 2025 season, prompting retirement and trade theories. Now, one voice claims the Vikings have reached out to Cincinnati about a trade.

Burrow trade theories keep resurfacing around the Vikings, and fans are not mad about them.

Generally speaking, it’s highly unlikely the Bengals trade the elite passer, but don’t tell that to hungry Vikings faithful, who would welcome a reunion between Burrow and wide receiver Justin Jefferson from their LSU days.

Joe Burrow Talk Keeps Circling the Vikings

Burrow-to-Vikings overtook Vikings discourse late last week.

Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow goes through his pregame warmup routine at Levi’s Stadium, loosening his arm and testing footwork on Oct. 29, 2023, in Santa Clara. The quiet preparation captured Burrow’s focus ahead of kickoff, a familiar scene as he calibrated timing and rhythm before facing San Francisco under the lights during early season action. Mandatory Credit: Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports

The Alleged Interest

SI.com‘s Grant Cohn is the current epicenter of Vikings-Burrow trade rumors.

He posted a video to X, formerly known as Twitter, last week, saying, “The Vikings want to get right back into contention. They’re planning to offer J.J. McCarthy and Jonathan Greenard, and two first‑round picks to the Cincinnati Bengals for Joe Burrow. If the Bengals say no, then they might go out and get Kirk Cousins, bring him back.”

Naturally, Vikings fans really want the theory to be real, so it was easy to classify the rumor as legitimate.

Offshoot Draft Website Doubles Down

Another party piled on, though it’s unclear if the source was just Cohn.

Walter Football tweeted Friday, “Just heard from a source that the Vikings reached out to the Bengals to trade for Joe Burrow. Asking price was too high. Bengals wanted multiple first-round picks, a defensive player, and J.J. McCarthy.”

It’s worth noting that Walter Football is almost exclusively a draft-themed website and strangely has a history of racist and sexist remarks, often tucked inside its draft analysis.

Nevertheless, casual fans saw the Walter Football tweet and interpreted it as further validation of Cohn’s take.

A King’s Ransom Trade

Truth be told, the price(s) mentioned by Cohn and Walter Football aren’t too far off reality. Trading for Burrow could involve multiple picks, an EDGE rusher — the Bengals need those, especially if they don’t make nice with Trey Hendrickson — and perhaps McCarthy. Aside from Malik Willis and possibly Mac Jones or Kyler Murray, other starting quarterbacks aren’t stranded on a deserted island waiting for the Bengals. McCarthy may be required in the theoretical swap.

What’s more, this April’s draft is not known for quarterback talent. Fernando Mendoza will go to the Las Vegas Raiders at pick No. 1, some team will draft Alabama’s Ty Simpson in the first 40 picks, and that’ll be it for high-profile quarterbacks early on. Passers like Arch Manning, LaNorris Sellers, and Dante Moore opted to return to school in 2026, making this class weak and somewhat reminiscent of the 2022 group.

Still, the Vikings, in theory, would have to decide if shipping McCarthy, Greenard, and three 1st-Rounders to Cincinnati for Burrow would be worth it. Usually, when such trades go down, the team receiving the king’s ransom — not the one getting the single player — “wins” the trade.

Matt Fitzgerald of Strype Hype, a Bengals-themed website, weighed in: “Would it stun me if the Bengals actually listened to a Joe Burrow trade proposal? Not in the slightest. This is still a cheap organization, plagued by conservatism, and the idea of rebooting the roster on a rookie QB contract, three young first-round draft assets, and a defensive veteran probably appeals to Mike Brown and those in his ownership orbit.”

“Do I personally want it to happen? No way. Nor do fans. The more realistic scenario for a Burrow trade is if Cincinnati misses the postseason again in 2026. At that point, I can’t imagine Joe would want to stick with the team. And why would he? The bottom-line veracity of these Joe Burrow trade rumors is less important or worth focusing on than the timing.”

Cincinnati would eat $56.5 million in dead cap if it traded Burrow before June 1st.

Joe Burrow exchanges handshakes with Seattle defenders Dre’Mont Jones and Bobby Wagner after the final whistle at Paycor Stadium, pausing to acknowledge competition on Oct. 15, 2023, in Cincinnati. The postgame moment reflected mutual respect, closing a physical matchup as players cooled down and crowds filtered out around the field after regulation ended late. Mandatory Credit: Kareem Elgazzar-USA TODAY Sports

Fitzgerald added, “Per OverTheCap.com, trading Burrow prior to June 1 would result in a net negative $8 million in 2026 cap space for Cincinnati. That’s another huge reason why 2027 feels way more feasible. Roast me for giving oxygen to these Vikings-Burrow reports if you want to.”

“Like it or not, the Joe Burrow trade talking point ain’t going away any time soon till the actual games start and a healthy Joe Brrr starts winning a lot of ’em.”

Instant Super Bowl Contendership

That doesn’t mean Minnesota shouldn’t do it. Burrow will turn 30 in December; he has about 5-10 years left of upper-echelon performance. The Vikings would rapidly morph into a Super Bowl contender and stay that way for the next five years, assuming wise free agency hauls and better draft processes.

Minnesota would have to nail picks outside of the 1st Round for the next three years, pray Burrow stays healthy, and it would contend for the NFC North and a Super Bowl annually. That’s the perk of netting Burrow.